The combination seafood platter and fresh ceviche are the safe bets, along with the chicken pesto pasta and, some nights, a fire dancer working the tables. Watch the water — bottled comes with a charge, but pitcher water is free if you ask for it that way.
It sits right on the beach, a 5-minute drive or 10-minute walk from Los Sueños, with live music some evenings and prices friendlier than you'd expect for a spot this close to the water in Herradura.